Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

newsworthy

Days of wine, roses, and free third-party billing come to end as UPS slaps on new transaction fee

Carrier imposes 2.5-percent charge on all third-party transactions, effective Jan. 4.

It's been standard practice in the parcel-shipping world for decades: A so-called third party, so named because it is neither a shipper nor receiver, uses a fulfillment house to store, pick, pack, and ship inventory. Carriers like UPS Inc. deliver the package and bill the third party, usually a merchant, for their services. Each third party has its own account number and its own set of pricing based on its unique shipping characteristics.

It's been a pretty good deal for everyone, except for the carrier. That's because large e-tailers with steep discounts would direct their fulfillment houses and so-called drop-ship vendors to use their third-party billing account numbers when their discounts were higher than those available to the actual shipper. While the carrier's cost of service didn't change because of the billing itself, its revenue would shrink because of the higher discounts the third party brought to the table.


Parcel carriers eager to win and keep business would offer third-party billing options knowing that discount cherry-picking existed, and that the risk of fraud was greater because a supplier could ship packages on behalf of its customer and to other consignees besides those that belonged to its customer. The third party would then receive its bill with shipping charges levied on transactions unrelated to it. UPS would be brought in, at its time and expense, to help resolve the conflicts.

Third-party billing was not a problem for carriers when it was a small part of the overall business. Today, however, third-party billing accounts for about 9 percent of UPS' and Memphis-based rival FedEx Corp.'s annual domestic revenues, due largely to the explosive growth of e-commerce transactions. At UPS alone, 11.64 percent of its shipments and 7.9 percent of its net charges are third-party billed, according to a source who asked not to be identified and who has access to much of the company's data. UPS moves more than 18 million pieces a day across its worldwide system.

In mid-October, UPS took action. The Atlanta-based giant imposed, effective Jan. 4, a 2.5-percent fee on all third-party billing services—the first time it has ever levied such a charge. FedEx does not have a similar fee, but given that the two companies frequently act in lockstep on pricing matters; that they have a virtual monopoly over B2B parcel traffic; and that there would be little visible downside for FedEx, no one would be surprised if it followed suit.

Susan L. Rosenberg, a UPS spokeswoman, said the new fee is designed to cover the overhead associated with managing these types of transactions, especially as e-commerce activity generates more of them. The current pricing structure underprices UPS' services in relation to the costs associated with providing them, said Rosenberg, noting that there is an "inappropriate level of volume discount" applied to a third-party billing transaction, and that UPS "incurs costs for which it may not be properly compensated."

Rosenberg said UPS always works to match incentive programs with a customer's shipping characteristics. She added, however, that "we're also going to get the percentage to cover overhead when it's a third party with smaller volume, where it costs us more to serve."

Those who will likely feel the most pain are small merchants who will now be forced to absorb a new charge on top of the carrier's regular annual rate increases. But any third party will likely sit up and take notice. Beyond trying to eliminate discount cherry-picking, the new charge is designed to modify customer behavior, according to Robert Persuit, director of business development of ShipMatrix, a unit of transport consultancy SJ Consulting. Persuit said UPS wants to migrate transactions away from third-party billing to a prepaid structure, where the fulfillment house become the payor and the merchant pays the house, thus eliminating UPS from any after-the-fact involvement. Persuit said prepaid billing is much simpler and less costly for UPS to understand and makes it easier for the carrier to quantify the costs of its service.

UPS CEO David P. Abney addressed the issue—albeit obliquely—during an Oct. 27 analyst call following UPS' announcement of its third-quarter results. In response to an analyst's query, Abney said the company wants to expand the third-party billing service in response to rising customer demand. Users benefit from "inventory handling and transportation savings associated with the service, as well as an ability for them to offer a broader line of products to both businesses and household consumers," he said.

Satish Jindel, head of SJ Consulting, said the charge is a cost-recovery initiative and not a way to wring profitable revenue out of UPS' customers. He said the current structure results in an "improper allocation of costs" for UPS because some are subsidizing the savings enjoyed by others.

The Latest

More Stories

two women shopping and buying goods

Study: Over 15% of all retail returns in 2024 were fraudulent

As retailers enter 2025, they continue struggling to slow the flood of returns fraud, which represented 15.14%--or nearly one-sixth—of all product returns in 2024, according to a report from Appriss Retail and Deloitte.

That percentage is even greater than the 13.21% of total retail sales that were returned. Measured in dollars, returns (including both legitimate and fraudulent) last year reached $685 billion out of the $5.19 trillion in total retail sales.

Keep ReadingShow less

Featured

chart of HR practices

Workplace report finds 5 trends sweeping the global labor pool

Waves of change are expected to wash over workplaces in the new year, highlighted by companies’ needs to balance the influx of artificial intelligence (AI) with the skills, capabilities, and perspectives that are uniquely human, according to a study from Top Employers Institute.

According to the Amsterdam-based human resources (HR) consulting firm, 2025 will be the year that the balance between individual and group well-being will evolve, blending personal empowerment with collective goals. The focus will be on creating environments where individual contributions enhance the overall strength of teams and organizations, and where traditional boundaries are softened to allow for greater collaboration and inclusion.

Keep ReadingShow less
a collage of bioelements packaging
Photo courtesy of Bioelements Group

Composting isn’t just for food waste anymore

The next time you buy a loaf of bread or a pack of paper towels, take a moment to consider the future that awaits the plastic it’s wrapped in. That future isn’t pretty: Given that most conventional plastics take up to 400 years to decompose, in all likelihood, that plastic will spend the next several centuries rotting in a landfill somewhere.

But a Santiago, Chile-based company called Bioelements Group says it has developed a more planet-friendly alternative. The firm, which specializes in biobased, biodegradable, and compostable packaging, says its Bio E-8i film can be broken down by fungi and other microorganisms in just three to 20 months. It adds that the film, which it describes as “durable and attractive,” complies with the regulations of each country in which Bioelements currently operates.

Keep ReadingShow less
a saia ltl freight truck on the road
Photo courtesy of Saia

Saia celebrates 100 years in trucking

When the trucking giant known as Saia LTL Freight was founded back in 1924, the “company” consisted of just one employee, Louis Saia Sr. of Houma, Louisiana. And it didn’t own a single truck: Saia removed the rear seats from his family car in order to haul his customers’ goods to New Orleans, where he traveled to pick up produce.

One hundred years later, the firm has been bought and sold, acquired some competitors, and moved to Johns Creek, Georgia. And it has added a few more workers. Saia today employs more than 15,000 people who operate 213 terminals across the country and a fleet of over 6,500 tractors and 22,000 trailers.

Keep ReadingShow less
2024 International Foodservice Distributor Association’s (IFDA) National Championship

2024 International Foodservice Distributor Association’s (IFDA) National Championship

Truckers, warehouse workers get some love

It’s probably safe to say that no one chooses a career in logistics for the glory. But even those accustomed to toiling in obscurity appreciate a little recognition now and then—particularly when it comes from the people they love best: their kids.

That familial love was on full display at the 2024 International Foodservice Distributor Association’s (IFDA) National Championship, which brings together foodservice distribution professionals to demonstrate their expertise in driving, warehouse operations, safety, and operational efficiency. For the eighth year, the event included a Kids Essay Contest, where children of participants were encouraged to share why they are proud of their parents or guardians and the work they do.

Keep ReadingShow less