Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

transportation report

On the right track

Thirty years since double-stack trains changed the game, intermodal folk step up their efforts to convert truck users.

On the right track

On April 27, 1984, a train operated by the Southern Pacific Transportation Co. left Los Angeles for South Kearny, N.J. This wasn't just another train, however. On board were containers stacked two-high on specially designed "wellcars." The lower boxes rested in a depression built into each car's center area, allowing the train to clear bridges and tunnels despite the higher cube.

The launch of the "Stacktrain," developed by steamship line American President Lines Ltd. and railcar manufacturer Thrall Car Manufacturing Co., became another "quantum leap" moment in the history of freight transportation in America. Railroads limited to hauling single trailers or containers on flatcars could now double their capacity with little additional investment. Shippers, meanwhile, would enjoy a second surge of fleet productivity just two years after Congress permitted the use of longer and heavier trucks on the country's interstates.


It's been a prolonged adolescence, but 30 years on, domestic intermodal—70 percent of which today moves in double-stack configuration—appears to have come of age. Its growth rate is currently about four times that of over-the-road truck. Shippers, brokers, and motor carriers concerned about road congestion, driver shortages, and volatile diesel prices continue to convert to intermodal; in the country's densely populated Eastern half, they are doing so over shorter stage lengths once reserved for trucks.

Intermodal has a ground-floor opportunity to capture up to 2 to 3 million truckloads crossing the U.S.-Mexican border each year (see sidebar). Intermodal executives are pursuing small to mid-sized brokers, truckers, and intermodal marketing companies (IMCs)—firms that retail intermodal service to shippers—with door-to-door services that didn't exist for them a decade ago. On the distant horizon is the $292 billion-a-year private truck fleet market, a category that may not be overly suitable for intermodal conversion because most moves are truck-friendly short-hauls from DC to store, but that could offer opportunities under certain scenarios.

During the 12-month period that ran through the end of 2014's first quarter, the domestic intermodal system moved 19,070 containers and trailers of dry van freight per calendar day, according to the consultancy FTR Associates. In the prior 12-month period, 18,573 units moved through the system daily. Larry Gross, a principal at FTR who specializes in intermodal, said the year-over-year increase—497 units per day—is significant. Conversion from over-the-road accounted for 15 percent of intermodal's year-on-year growth, Gross estimates.

A TOUGH SELL
Intermodal executives aware their industry has a spotty track record of operational consistency focus more time these days on education than anything else. To newcomers, they tout intermodal's benefits (economies of scale, fuel efficiency, environmental friendliness, etc.). To former users that may have been burned years ago, they say that multibillion dollar investments in ramps and terminals have brought intermodal close to being cost and service competitive with single-driver truck operators, mostly in the East.

"Intermodal is very much a truck-like business today. It's just done a little differently," said Matt Meeks, head of ABF Multimodal, a unit of Fort Smith, Ark.-based ArcBest Corp. (formerly Arkansas Best Corp.) that manages the company's intermodal business. To reinforce the tutorial, Schneider National Inc., the trucking and logistics giant and a big intermodal user, often sends a director-level executive on customer calls to explain the ins and outs of the service, according to Jim Filter, the Green Bay, Wis.-based company's vice president, intermodal commercial sales. It can be a tough sell, Filter admitted: Some shippers still have a hard time grasping intermodal; others worry about erratic rail service levels. Some potential users "think they need a rail siding to ship intermodal," he added.

Aware of these concerns, executives take pains to educate potential users in situations where intermodal might not work. The cost of truck dray services to and from intermodal ramps is a crucial element. The longer the dray distance, the higher the total expense. Service to and from high-density markets like Chicago and the Ohio Valley make dray service economical. However, the returns begin diminishing when the service hits lower-density markets.

A ratio of dray miles to over-the-road linehaul miles above 30 percent would likely put intermodal at a cost disadvantage to truck, according to Sam Niness, assistant vice president and general manager of "Thoroughbred Direct," the intermodal unit of Norfolk, Va.-based rail Norfolk Southern Corp. (NS). For example, if the truck mileage is 800 miles and a shipper and consignee are each 100 miles from their respective ramps, a 50-percent ratio (truck mileage divided by the total round-trip dray miles on both ends) would pose a conversion challenge, based on Niness's formula. However, change that truck haul to 2,000 miles, and intermodal becomes an attractive option. In an effort to reduce dray costs, a growing number of NS's customers are working with the railroad to position new distribution centers close to its ramps, Niness said.

OPENING THE DOORS
The past 10 years have seen dramatic changes in how intermodal is marketed. In a move to attract freight brokers, railroads have made intermodal available on the spot market, the world brokers live in. In addition, the rails now offer brokers door-to-door services by bolting drayage operations onto the traditional ramp-to-ramp business. While this has benefited all brokers, it has been a particular boon to smaller players, which had to find their own dray services but often lacked the scale or network contacts to do it economically.

In 2007, Union Pacific Railroad Co. created a unit called "Streamline" catering to smaller users that previously could only secure ramp-to-ramp service from their rail partners. By leveraging its enormous resources, Omaha, Neb.-based Streamline gave users the opportunity to offer end-to-end intermodal solutions to their customers, according to Kari A. Kirchhoefer, Streamline's president.

Rail intermodal folk contend that the ability to sell a door-to-door product has demystified intermodal service for many shippers and has opened doors previously closed. Potential users are "amazed at how easy it is," said Niness of Thoroughbred.

One objective of intermodal executives is to migrate intermediaries away from transactional business into long-term strategic relationships. Streamline, for example, has developed annualized rate programs for repeat broker customers, and pledges equipment and dray capacity in return for freight volume commitments. Kirchhoefer said many brokers working with Streamline shifted to the relationship model once they became confident in the service.

TECH RULES
The ubiquity of IT tools has enhanced intermodal's value proposition. Some large users have said they would like to see better data integration between their platforms and the rails' so that information doesn't have to be entered twice. On balance, however, the expanded use of technology has helped make users' lives easier, which is a good thing for providers.

It is commonplace today for users to share data on their current truck business with the railroads, which will, in turn, overlay their intermodal schedules on top of that to determine where rail service might be a better fit. C.H. Robinson Worldwide Inc., the third-party logistics service specialist, doesn't rely on published schedules; instead, it uses proprietary technology to analyze and assess intermodal opportunities, according to Phil Shook, director of intermodal for Eden Prairie, Minn.-based Robinson.

Robinson's analysis focuses on analyzing "normalized" ramp-to-ramp transit times to determine the highest likelihood of schedule variance, said Shook. Big intermediaries like Robinson have the resources to manage the dray process themselves.

Streamline offers an online visual graph that lights up to show where intermodal service is available, where ramps are located, and their proximity to key points of interest. Streamline's site also compares intermodal door-to-door and over-the-road pricing, but only shows the potential savings in each lane; access to the actual rates is limited to customers.

Then there are the disrupters like Chris Ricciardi, chief product officer of Chicago-based Logistical Labs. Ricciardi is directing a project that would consolidate all intermodal information in one pOréal. Today, users have to visit multiple sites to compare rates, services, and schedules from various providers.

Ricciardi's model is based on the premise that the one-stop online shop that has worked so well in areas like travel can be applied to the intermodal world. "We want," he said, "to be the Expedia of intermodal."

The Latest

More Stories

ITS Logistics truck carrying Sherwin Williams products
ITS Logistics

Transportation challenges, solved

Sometimes, all you need is the right partner to solve your logistics problems.

In 2021, global paint supplier Sherwin Williams faced driver and hazardous material (hazmat) capacity constraints: There simply weren’t enough hazmat drivers available in its fleet to maintain the company’s 90% fleet utilization rate expectations for key partner store deliveries while also meeting growing demand for service. Those challenges threatened to become even more acute in the future, as a competing paint supply company began to scale back its operations in the Pacific Northwest, leaving Sherwin Williams with an opportunity to fill the gap.

Keep ReadingShow less

Featured

drone flying through warehouse

Robotic revolution

Robots are revolutionizing factories, warehouses, and distribution centers (DCs) around the world, thanks largely to heavy investments in the technology between 2019 and 2021. And although investment has slowed since then, the long-term outlook calls for steady growth over the next four years. According to data from research and consulting firm Interact Analysis, revenues from shipments of industrial robots are forecast to grow nearly 4% per year, on average, between 2024 and 2028 (see Exhibit 1).

market forecast for industrial robots - revenues graphEXHIBIT 1: Market forecast for industrial robots - revenuesInteract Analysis

Keep ReadingShow less
Freight Science dashboard screen
Freight Science

High-tech solution helps truckload carrier drive change

The trucking industry faces a range of challenges these days, particularly when it comes to load planning—a resource-intensive task that often results in suboptimal decisions, unnecessary empty miles, late deliveries, and inefficient asset utilization. What’s more, delays in decision-making due to a lack of real-time insights can hinder operational efficiency, making cost management a constant struggle.

Truckload carrier Paper Transport Inc. (PTI) experienced this firsthand when the company sought to expand its over the-road (OTR), intermodal, and brokerage offerings to include dedicated fleet services for high-volume shippers—adding a layer of complexity to the business. The additional personnel required for such a move would be extremely costly, leading PTI to investigate technology solutions that could help close the gap.

Keep ReadingShow less
indigo software screenshot WMS

Aptean adds British WMS vendor in latest acquisition

The Georgia-based enterprise software vendor Aptean today said it had acquired Indigo Software Ltd., a British provider of purpose-built warehouse management and logistics software solutions.

Terms of the deal were not disclosed, but Aptean said the move will add new capabilities to its warehouse management and supply chain management offerings for manufacturers, wholesalers, distributors, retailers, and 3PLs. Aptean currently provides enterprise resource planning (ERP), transportation management systems (TMS), and product lifecycle management (PLM) platforms.

Keep ReadingShow less
schneider app screenshot for owner operators

Schneider seeks more business with owner-operators

Transportation and logistics service provider Schneider National Inc. is reaching out to owner-operators, encouraging them to do more business with the Wisconsin company using an updated digital platform.

Schneider says its FreightPower platform now offers owner-operators significantly more access to Schneider’s range of freight options. That can help drivers to generate revenue and strengthen their business through: increased access to freight, high drop and hook rates of over 95% of loads, and a trip planning feature that calculates road miles.

Keep ReadingShow less